|
|
News and Notes
In spite of these shortcomings
and in spite of the obvious lack of ability on
the part of the participants to express themselves
clearly and coherently, the discussion sessions
proved to be the most important part of the three-fold
program of the wokshop, Dr.B.C Deva. With his
refreshing sense of humor, helped to save the
heated discussions from becoming bitter wrangles.
Dr Deva and prof Ashoka Ranade with his keep sense
of relevance kept the discussion on the right-path.
The actual demonstration given by the singer-participants
while discussing certain controversial issue,
along with the playback sessions and the concerts,
provided the live context of musical activity
to the theoretical discussions.
The recordings obtained from the sound library
of the Akademi, included some rare sample of Khyals
from Ustad Altaf Hussein, Ustad Aman Ali, Pt.
Anant Manohar, Pt, Bholanath Bhatt, Ustad Chand
Khan, Smt, Mogubai Kurdikar, Ustad Bade Gulam
Ali ,Pt Ramchatur Mallik, Ustad Mushtaq, Hussein,
Ustad Moujuddin Khan, and Ustad Wahid Hussein.
One felt that for the benefit of students of music
such rare samples from the collection of the Academia
should be made available at various other centers
too.
Though the absence of any Kirtana-style singers
was badly felt, the singers who performed authentically
represented the major trends in contemporary Khyal-singing.
Smt.Kamal Tambe's rendering of Poorvi, Chhaya
Nat and Raisa Kanada were in the truly Jaipur
style. The compositions were sung with at most
percussion the framework of the ragas were established
with great solidity, and the patterning of alaps
and taans was highly complex. Smt.Kishori Amonkar's
concert came as a direct contrast; though trained
in the same gharana, the raga structures of Bhimpalas
and Bhoop became more supple in her had; gifted
with an extraordinarily rich voice, Smt Amonkar
prefers to explore how far she could deviate from
the raga-framework without simple ragas as well
as in his clear and lucid elaboration of his themes.
|